Roger Nusbaum submits: On Saturday, a reader left this link from DealBook about Burton Malkiel's thoughts on active management along with the other side of the discussion as observed by James Tierney from WP Stewart, an active manager running a very concentrated portfolio with an outstanding track record versus the market going back to the 1970s.
You've heard the basics of Malkiel's argument before: no one can consistently pick winning stocks and no one can consistently time the market. In addition to this difficulty, Malkiel also notes the problem of human emotions getting in the way. I imagine the argument in favor of active management is not new to you either. Among other things mentioned the active managers say that there are people who can consistently beat the market.
Complete Story »